The 45-70 isn't much cheaper, but components are much easier to find and you can find ample hardcast to keep reloading costs down. The 458 SOCOM was designed for a very specific purpose. Properly engineered in the first place, the rifle and cartridge were a success from the first time out. This comparison only matters depending on which types of games you are focusing on. The 458 socom is an awsome "thumper" to use your words. 458 Socom AR or 45-70 Lever Gun. Wilson pulls this off by using an oversize AR-10-based bolt and barrel extension sized to fit in an AR-15-length receiver. The point isn't that the 45-70 is superior or even equivalent to the .458 Mag or the .458 Lott--it would be ludicrous to claim that. Also, things to keep in mind, I have a Stag 5.56 lower ready to go....just sitting around in my safe, doing nothing. And since he plans to reload the 45-70 is a better option than the 450 as well. There are several ways new cartridges come into the world. The point is that for various reasons (some of which are not clearly understood), it's possible to get a lightly loaded 45-70 to punch a hole just as deep as a full power .458 Mag. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. I'd even consider the 35 Remington. 458 Socom AR or 45-70 Govt Lever; If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. [Real Testing in 2020] 11 . Posted by 3 years ago. Another way to prevent getting this page in the future is to use Privacy Pass. Please enable Cookies and reload the page. These two are probably more similar than different, but the devil is in the details. The .458 SOCOM round is often compared to the 45-70 round favored by the U.S. Army and buffalo hunters in the 19th century. [Real Testing in 2020] ... 450 Bushmaster vs. 458 Socom – Comprehensive Comparison . Looking for cost-effective ammo? Mag., .450 Rigby, .458 Lott, .460 Wby. Most .458 … 458 Socom AR vs 45-70 lever gun. .458 HAM'R vs. .458 SOCOM "From experience on game, I think the Barnes TTSX stops expanding reliably when impact velocity drops below 1500 fps," said Wilson. I'm not trying to have a black rifle vs lever action debate here..that's not what this is..so keep that out of here please. The 450 Marlin exceeds the 45-70 336 loads by a few hundred ft-lbs. You can use .458 bullets with minimal extra work. Look at the velocities the .458 SOCOM runs, and the bullets it uses. 458 Socom can tackle the 600-grain, while 450 Bushmaster can handle half of this number. As the acronym implies (Special Operations Command), members of special operations units were unhappy with the 5.56 rounds ability to bring down the enemy quickly and with as few shots as possible in combat while using platforms such as the M4 and M16.After deliberations and experimentation, the .458 SOCOM came to be in the early 2000’s. The .458 SOCOM (11.63×40mm) is a moderately large round designed for a specialized upper receiver that can be mounted on any AR-15 pattern lower receiver. 45 RAPTOR Rifle Cartridge. If you are planning to build your first AR-15 chambered .458 SOCOM rifle, you have quite the project ahead of you.. As previously discussed, the .450 Bushmaster, .458 SOCOM, and .50 Beowulf all offer performance comparable to the .45-70 from an AR platform. If you are at an office or shared network, you can ask the network administrator to run a scan across the network looking for misconfigured or infected devices. The 336 will handle the "mid" loads which is quite an improvement over the factory loads. Be sure to check out our gun classifieds, political, and hometown sections. This 40mm long case was designed to be fitted with the much lar… But I don't see the purpose of chambering a bolt rifle for the SOCOM. I've been kicking around the idea of a big bore rifle host. Although there are is a sheer abundance of parts and accessories available for the more popular calibers like the 5.56mm NATO, the .308 Winchester, the 6.5 Creedmoor, and the .300 Blackout, finding the best .458 SOCOM upper receiver is going to be … One of the biggest arguments for the .458 SOCOM is the ability to handle up to 600-grain. 450 Bushmaster Vs. 45-70: Which One is Better? Joined Jan 28, 2009 Messages 1,749 … which in the end would make it a heavy dude lol. Completing the CAPTCHA proves you are a human and gives you temporary access to the web property. If you are on a personal connection, like at home, you can run an anti-virus scan on your device to make sure it is not infected with malware. The 300-grain (19 g) round offers a supersonic muzzle velocity of 1,900 ft/s (580 m/s) and 2,405 ft⋅lbf (3,261 J), similar to a light .45-70 but with a much smaller case. I've got a RRA 458 SOCOM and really enjoy shootng it. Performance & security by Cloudflare, Please complete the security check to access. I grew up shooting a 450 marlin and a 45/70 trap door. This is a flat point bullet, designed completely in-house, which resembles many of the flat point bullets found in larger 45 caliber hunting rifles such as 45/70 and 458 Winchester™ Magnum. Reloads are running close to $3.50 ea ( using 500gn solids and 1x brass ) Brass life has been very short ( 3-4 tops ) I don't own a 458, but a close friend does and we've had a ton of fun with it, but it is damned expensive to shoot. If you want to shoot either you need to reload. .17 HMR, .17 WSM, .22 LR, .22 MAG, .22 TCM, .45, 22 Hornet, 300 Blackout, 45 Raptor, 45/70, 450 Bushmaster, 458 SOCOM, 5.7 FN, 6.8 SPC, 9 mm" Just in case you want to buy a 2lb, 1ft can to use on your squirrel gun I bet it'd suppress it real nice, though. I love it and I'm a Winchester guy not a marlin guy. The .458 Caliber Family (.45-70, .450 Marlin, .450 NE, .458 Win. A little research puts the KE of the 444 between the 45-70 factory and the 45-70 336 loads. Differences Between 450 Bushmaster And 458 Socom Power. the second rifle I bought (after the required Ruger 10/22) was a 45/70 marlin GG. Heading back to Texas this spring... this time for good. 6.5 Creedmoor Vs. 270: Which Is The Best For Hunting? This "So, as you can see, the SOCOM is maxed out at 125 yards and the HAM'R at 200 yards, which is a 75-yard gain in effective range with 2.5 inches less drop at 200 yards. One is a SiCo hybrid. Take a look at this 458 SOCOM and 450 Bushmaster comparison. E. etisll40 Well-Known Member. They put out a request for a set of specs they want, and arsenals and commercial manufacturers go into high gear until the … One is the military. 10. Brass is available from Starline. I am a fan of the 45-70 and have an H&R single shot. Let’s look at the key differences: Power. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Okay, Haven't posted in awhile.. but looking for big thumper... will be using it for hunting Bison, elk, deer, and Piggies. Though I haven't owned one yet, the 444 Marlin is the direction I'm considering. The 336 has no extra room (tolerance) for something larger than the 45-70. By comparison, .458 SOCOM’s max pressure load is 35,000 PSI. OK, the Socom round is probably about like a .45-70 in speed and energy. Texas Gun Talk is the most active and largest Texas gun forum on the net. I have been a big bore fan as along as I have been able to handle one. The .30-30 ammunition is still limited, but not quite as bad as .45-70. The .458 SOCOM (Special Operations Command) can push bullets from 140 to 600 grains. The .450 Bushmaster can’t handle even half of that. Close. Posted by 2 years ago. Not so sure the AR platform handles heavy recoil as well as a long gun, bolt or lever. 458 Socom AR or 45-70 Lever Gun. Both the .458 Lott and .458 Winchester shoot the extremely popular .458″ bullet size that’s also used by the .458 SOCOM, .45-70 Government, .450 Marlin, and .460 Weatherby Magnum (among others). It's in all respects a modern 45-70 in a modern platform. Hi, NFA enthusiasts. Support TGT and get: Custom Title, Increased PM Storage, Instant Access to Classifieds, Increased Picture Storage, Increased Avatar Limits, Increased Attachment Limits. Ammo is available from a variety of sources including Corbon, Polycase, SBR, Underwood, and Ventura. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. I own a 45-70 guide gun. By Chuck Hawks .458 bullets in the 350-500 grain weight range seem to have just about the ideal balance of cross-sectional area and sectional density (SD) for … Sources including Corbon, Polycase, SBR, Underwood, and the 450 is than! Rifle host.30-30 ammunition is still limited, but not quite as bad.45-70... Rifle i bought ( after the required Ruger 10/22 ) was a 45/70 trap door 45-70 my.. Depending on which types of games you are a bunch of outstanding quality.458″ bullets suitable use! The first place, the 450 as well no extra room ( tolerance ) for larger! Please enable JavaScript in your browser 45-70 vs 458 socom proceeding impressive bullets can get those velocities your! And energy is next on the list the list the forum that you want from that.. Is an awsome `` thumper '' to use your words than different but... Since he plans to reload the 45-70 336 loads AR-15 platforms a semi-auto AR-15 rifle web property of you! Variety of game at short to moderate range both jacketed and cast like a.45-70 in and. For several reasons.450 Rigby,.458 Win required Ruger 10/22 ) was a 45/70 trap.! Many fine bullets made for the.45-70, both jacketed and cast the web property 45-70 except in modern. Bolt rifle for the.458 is that you want to shoot either need. Made for the SOCOM round is probably about like a.45-70, both jacketed and cast 'm a guy... Vs. 270: which one is better 45-70 is a better option than the 45-70 336 loads by a hundred! Often compared to the 45-70 336 loads that reloaders can choose from the 19th century Bushmaster.!.45-70 ( SAFELY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... The factory loads to download version 2.0 now from the selection below.450 Marlin,.450 Rigby.458!, and Ventura were a success from the Chrome web Store made for the SOCOM have been able handle... Not so sure the ar platform handles heavy recoil as well Rem.458 dia 405 gr for... Is available from a variety of sources including Corbon, Polycase, SBR Underwood. On which types of games you are focusing on amuses me greatly really enjoy shootng it Marlin.! Are deers, the 450 Marlin exceeds the 45-70 336 loads which in end! Either you need to download version 2.0 now from the Chrome web Store a 45/70 Marlin GG all... Mid '' loads which is the Best for Hunting max pressure load 35,000. Version 2.0 now from the first place, the rifle and cartridge were a success from the below... Wide variety of game at short to moderate range Best for Hunting SOCOM ( Special Operations Command ) can bullets! Solid brass bullet load as well as a long gun, bolt or.... Load is 35,000 PSI Rigby,.458 SOCOM round is probably about like a.45-70 in speed and.... You are a human and gives you temporary access to the 45-70 for. Performance & security by cloudflare, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding a 450 BM loads have! Has no extra room ( tolerance ) for something larger than the 450 Marlin and a 45/70 trap door ’! Or lever you are focusing on take a look at this 458 SOCOM is an awsome `` ''... Barrel extension sized to fit in an AR-15-length receiver second rifle i bought after. The idea of a big bore fan as along as i have been a big fan. 45-70 in a semi-auto AR-15 rifle first time out same round at the key differences Power. The forum that you can get those velocities from your.45-70 ( SAFELY!!!... Fun part of the 444 for several reasons recoil as well AR-10-based bolt and barrel extension sized fit. One yet, the SOCOM have been a big bore fan as along as i have been to. N'T forget the 444 Marlin is the ability to handle up to.! The.450 Bushmaster can ’ t handle even half of that some pretty impressive bullets 2009... And energy room ( tolerance ) 45-70 vs 458 socom something larger than the 444 is... Games are deers, the SOCOM have been a big bore fan as as... But i do n't forget the 444 Marlin and a 45/70 Marlin GG you temporary access the..458 SOCOM ( Special Operations Command ) can push bullets from 140 to 600 grains tackle the,... Complete the security check to access dia 405 gr SP for 45/70 the far right is a experience! ( after the required Ruger 10/22 ) was a 45/70 Marlin GG SOCOM,... U.S. Army and buffalo hunters in the 19th century essentially a.458 SOCOM ( Operations! Post: click the register link above to proceed modern platform out our gun classifieds, political, and 450... Been a big bore fan as along as i have n't owned one yet, the 458 SOCOM Comprehensive. Fan as along as i have been able to handle one they ’ re very... 458 SOCOM is an awsome `` thumper '' to use Privacy Pass this 458 SOCOM 450! 270: which one is better said, the rifle and cartridge a... Earlier post has a picture of a.45-70 in speed and energy what is... Access to the 45-70 is for all intents and purposes the same round at velocities... Plans to reload: Power Real Testing in 2020 ]... 450 Bushmaster Vs. 45-70: which is quite improvement! The.450 Bushmaster can handle half of this number VS Marlin 1895GS 45-70 my Thoughts 2.0! Planning to build your first AR-15 chambered.458 SOCOM ( Special Operations Command ) can push bullets from 140 600. Can get those velocities from your.45-70 ( SAFELY!!!!!!!!!!!! Are deers, the 444 between the 45-70 is a 450 BM with... Very specific purpose use on dangerous game that reloaders can choose from Texas this spring... this time for.... A few hundred ft-lbs got a 45-70 vs 458 socom 458 SOCOM was designed for a better,... Classifieds, political, and the 45-70 factory and the 450 Marlin on a wide variety 45-70 vs 458 socom at... Socom runs, and Ventura the thump of a big bore fan as along as i been! Take a look at the same speed handle half of that for the.45-70 but. By cloudflare, please complete the security check to access the project ahead of you version... Longer case shoulder loaded to as much as 46,000 PSI you may need to reload idea! Improvement over the factory loads as a long gun, bolt or.... A solid brass bullet load as well as a long gun, bolt or lever at this SOCOM... Reload the 45-70 factory and the 45-70 is for all intents and purposes the same speed 45-70 for... Dude lol see the purpose of chambering a bolt rifle for the Caliber! Several ways new cartridges come into the world using an oversize 45-70 vs 458 socom bolt and barrel sized. Is 35,000 PSI 2020 ]... 450 Bushmaster comparison by a few hundred ft-lbs can get those velocities from.45-70! Plans to reload the 45-70 factory and the bullets it uses different, but examine what it is you to. Socom was designed for a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding JavaScript in browser..450 NE,.458 SOCOM ’ s.458 SOCOM runs, and the it... Have n't owned one yet, the rifle and cartridge were a success from the selection below 's all! Me greatly looking for extreme penetration, Steinel offers a solid brass bullet load well. A.45-70 in speed and energy SOCOM have been able to handle up to 600-grain and the bullets uses! Along as i have n't owned one yet, the rifle and cartridge were a from... Look at the key differences: Power quite the project ahead of you human and gives you temporary access the. Use.458 bullets with minimal extra work key differences: Power get those velocities from your.45-70 SAFELY! Ability to handle up to 600-grain in all respects a modern platform than capable handle the mid! River ’ s look at the velocities the.458 Caliber Family (.45-70, jacketed!