When we got our hands on a Sig Sauer P320 Carry to review, though, we were eager to see if it would unseat the Glock. The P226 was a variant of the company’s popular P220, the official sidearm of armies worldwide, from Switzerland (naturally) to Japan. GunTweaks.com and its authors do not assume any responsibility, directly or indirectly, for the safety of readers attempting to use or misuse information, instructions, or procedures provided herein. Overall, the Glock is a bit lighter than the P320, mostly because of the amount of polymer in the pistol. The gun weighs two ounces shy of two pounds with a loaded magazine. ... 22 +1 (40 S&W) Sig Sauer P320 XCompact . The SIG P320 Compact has very similar dimensions as the Glock 19. Shootout: Sig Sauer's P320 vs. Glock's 19 (Which Is Better?) Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G19x and Sig Sauer P320 M17 In 1986, a SEAL demonstrating the Beretta for a visiting VIP was injured when the rear portion of the pistol slide broke off, sending the slide crashing into the sailor’s face. Unlike the Beretta there is no manual safety—all of the mechanical safeties are instead incorporated into the fire-control system to prevent accidental discharge. Both the SIG P320 and the Glock 21 are robustly made, reliable, have good fit and finish and use polymer frames. by Gun News Daily One of the most common questions we get asked here at GND is whether you should buy a Glock 19 or a Sig P320. The P226’s main competitor, the Glock 17, also uses the Petter-Browning locking system, as do many contemporary pistols. Sauer & Sohn was at the time Germany’s oldest firearms manufacturer, founded in 1751, and traditionally had an emphasis on sporting arms. In the mid-1980s, the U.S. military finally moved away from the M1911A1 .45 caliber handgun to a new pistol, the Beretta 92FS. I recently picked up a Glock 32, which is pretty much a Glock 23 but in 357 Sig. A Swiss industrial company that makes everything from rail cars to handguns, Schweizerische Industrie Gesellschaft (SIG) was founded in 1853 in Neuhausen am Rheinfall, Switzerland, and was the brains behind the SIG P210 handgun. Both are fine handguns with excellent reputations but which would you choose? In contrast, the Glock once again did not have any major malfunctions. Glock vs. Sig Sauer: How the Navy SEALs Went from the P226 to the Glock 19. Sig Sauer P320 vs Glock 19. by Norman Turner - Last updated December 6, 2020. 25 has been a constant companion for SEALs over the past three decades, including operations in Panama, Somalia, Haiti, the Balkans, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria and other countries. 25 has a 4.4-inch barrel, nearly half an inch shorter than the Beretta M9, and the handgun is chambered for nine-millimeter parabellum. 25, were fielded in 1989. The frame is made from a steel alloy, while the slide is made from stainless steel for increased strength, and the slide is finished in Nitron for corrosion resistance. Glock 17 vs SIG P226: A British soldier aiming Glock 17 at the shooting range (Photo: XY) Upside. Only you can figure out what you want. However, due to the Glock’s. The handgun was a derivative of the original Sig P10, a highly successful handgun in its own right, but updated with modern features. The Sig P320 is often compared to the next pistol on our list, the Glock 19. Known as the M9 in U.S. service, the Beretta was touted as a modern, safer, easier to shoot handgun with twice the ammunition capacity as the .45. © Copyright 2021 Center for the National Interest All Rights Reserved, Uzi: The Israeli Machine Gun That Conquered the World, The M4: The Gun U.S. Army Loves to Go to War With, Why Glock Dominates the Handgun Market (And Better than Sig Sauer and Beretta), North Korea and America’s Second Summit: We Asked 76 Experts to Predict the Results. Both of these handguns are tough and reliable. P320 vs Glock Torture Test: ... 17 Gen 4 has been the king – it had only one, single malfunction before it shot clear. A basic Sig 229 is probably going to cost around $800 new and $650 or so used. We compare two excellent Concealed Carry pistols that will serve equally well on the nightstand or Range Day. SIG P320 vs Glock 19. Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Contribute; Contact; Glock . I’m trying to decide between the P320 M17 and the Glock 19/17/19X/G45. 25. When the P320 came out, SIG claimed it to be the single most accurate striker-fired gun out there. It has a simple manual of arms- once it is loaded and in service, simply draw, aim, trigger press. When we got our hands on a Sig Sauer P320 Carry to review, though, we were eager to see if it would unseat the Glock. The SEALs put in an initial request for eight hundred P226s and the first pistols, officially named Mk. I haven’t shot the Sig P220, but I’m looking at a P226 TacOps and even at a Glock 22. The grouping we got was a bit better than the one we got with Glock 19. 25. It may be one of the best 9mm in the market today, considering its size, ergo, capacity, and accuracy. A Glock costs about $80 to produce and a Sig costs about $300 to produce, so clearly higher production cost is a higher cost. Maybe it fits your hand, great. The P226 was promptly put into extensive environmental trials that simulated the operating environment of SEAL units, including immersion in sand, salt water and mud. The M9 was adopted by all arms of the military, including U.S. Navy’s elite SEAL Team Six. Sig Sauer had a good quarter-century run arming America’s naval commandos, and now the torch is passed to Glock. ​At GunTweaks, we try to put every handgun we review through a standardized reliability trial we simply call the “dirt test”, which in simplest terms involves chucking the pistol in the dirt and seeing how many shots it takes to behave normally afterwards. The Mk. While the Army, the Marine Corps and even the rest of the Navy toted the Beretta M9 pistol, Navy SEALs carried an entirely different handgun altogether: the Sig Sauer P226. The Sig Sauer P320. When a variant of the SIG Sauer P320 was adopted by the U.S. Army over the Glock as the M17, it was the first win for SIG in the handgun market in a long time. Glock 17 vs Sig P320: On the Range In my experience, both guns are easy to shoot, feature low recoil, and are both very accurate. I currently carry a P320 using a compact slide on a sub grip. You can follow him on Twitter: @KyleMizokami. Although the injury was relatively minor and only a few pistols showed signs of slide cracking (a deficiency Beretta later fixed), the SEALs wanted a new pistol. Reliability. 25s will carry on, the SEALs will gradually replace them with newer Glocks. In the wet test, both guns did much worse. Sig’s P365 and P320 offer two great options for concealed carry. All of this meant that SEALs assigned to Team Six placed a great deal of wear and tear on their pistols. The Glock is grip length is very close to the sub compact P320 grip. Both are great guns, of course, as proven by their loyal followings, but there seems to be no real consensus on which is the best. (This first appeared several months ago.). The Glock 17 is significantly cheaper than the SIG Sauer (although this is not specific to the P226). For three decades, the U.S. Navy’s Sea Air Land (SEAL) special-forces teams relied on a pistol apart from the rest of the American military. Trained for counterterrorism missions, Team Six operators honed their close-quarter shooting skills to a sharp edge, and during the 1980s it was rumored Team Six’s small arms ammunition budget was greater than that of the entire U.S. Marine Corps. Any modifications to a firearm should be performed by a licensed gunsmith only. 25 can be operated as either a single- or double-action pistol, and has a decocker for safely releasing the hammer without firing a round. The Glock 19 is top of the crop when it comes to popularity. While Mk. Value is subjective. The Glock is polymer-2 based, while the SIG is made mostly of steel. Striker-Fired Compact Pistol . The SEALs put in an initial request for eight hundred P226s and the first pistols, officially named Mk. The Glock did well in the so-called “salt fog test” that tested for metal corrosion, an important consideration given the tendency for SEALs to immerse themselves fully in salt water. For a long time, the Glock 17 Gen 4 has been the king – it had only one, single malfunction before it shot clear. Instead, the SEALs picked the P226 handgun. Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G23 Gen4 and Sig Sauer P320 XCompact. Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G22 Gen4 and Sig Sauer P320 M17 Modifications may void warranties, create an unsafe firearm, and/or may cause injury or death. The Sig 229 is a gorgeous piece of mechanical engineering. Given the quality that is to be expected with both of these manufacturers, it … Tweet. The contents of GunTweaks.com are produced for informational purposes only. 25, were fielded in 1989. The trigger pull and trigger action remain the same for every shot. It is relatively cheap-US $550-$600. They also both come with accessory rails for attaching lights and lasers. If you want to sell a whole bunch of guns, get an Army contract. Both of our competitors are striker-fired pistols chambered in 9mm, which is one of the most popular self-defense rounds. P320 XCompact. In late 2015, Naval Special Warfare Command made the decision to add the Glock 19, the compact nine-millimeter version of the Glock series of handguns, to the SEALs’ handgun arsenal. Both also use a DAO (double action only) trigger mechanism.So apart from the two pistols being manufactured by two companies well known for their products’ reliability, they share a few similar things. The Sig malfunctioned 15 times in the first magazine, though it again beat the Glock which malfunctioned 18 times, although neither gun shot clear. Sig Sauer P320 Sub-compact or Sig P365: The Final Verdict When it comes to P320 sub-compact or P-365, our final verdict declares the P-365 pistol as the winner. Hey guys. The Mk. If it doesn't, you can't change it. The manufacturer suggested retail price for these gun is around $500 for a new Glock, and $900 or $1000 for a new SIG Sauer. Share. will tend to be about equal Developed by the German-Swiss arms manufacturer Sig Sauer for the competition to replace the M1911A1, the P226 had come in second place to the M9. I know this is a Sig Sauer Forum but I did this same thread over at a Glock Forum and wanted balanced answers so I’m doing it both places. \r \r!IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION!\rSig P320 Voluntary Safety Upgrade:\r\r\rSig P320 Drop Safety Initial Info:\r\r \rIf you are interested in more information on either pistol, check out our individual reviews on each one.\r\rGlock 19: \rSig P320: \rGSSF(Glock … VS. Sig Sauer . The two pistols were dirtied up using DE and tested twice, once dry and once after being dunked in water. Here is a Glock 19 Gen 4 vs Sig Sauer P320 XCompact range comparison. Their compact sizes and high magazine capacities make them excellent choices for everyday carry. They're also easy to customize. Kyle Mizokami is a defense and national-security writer based in San Francisco who has appeared in the Diplomat, Foreign Policy, War is Boring and the Daily Beast. Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G26 Gen4 and Sig Sauer P320 Nitron Subcompact In the sum total of all shots fired, the Sig bested the Glock by malfunctioning 27 times, whereas the Glock malfunctioned 30 times. The compact P320 grip is about 3/4 inch longer. Like the 210, the 226 used the Petter-Browning locking system, which updated John Browning’s 1911 locking system with improvements made by Swiss engineer Charles Petter, including eliminating the barrel bushing and using a full length guide rod. Sig Sauer itself had a great deal of history. The P226 in SEAL service became known as the Mk. Calibers: 9mm Luger . Recommended: Uzi: The Israeli Machine Gun That Conquered the World, Recommended: The M4: The Gun U.S. Army Loves to Go to War With, Recommended: Why Glock Dominates the Handgun Market (And Better than Sig Sauer and Beretta), According to small-arms historian Kevin Dockery, the SEALs tested the then new Glock 17 pistol as a possible replacement. On the SIG P320 the grip is what it is. A Glock 19 can cost as little as $525 new with two mags. The Mk. They notably disregarded Glock, so a number of people will wonder if the Glock 19 vs Sig P320 is really a losing proposition for the Austrian plastic fantastic. We tested it with .40 S&W ammo, and we have to say — it did not disappoint us. That gives a pistol pedigree, which will also result in … Not only do these two guns look the same, they also perform just about on the same level. G23 Gen4. 25 has a 4.4-inch barrel, nearly half an inch shorter than the Beretta M9, and the handgun is chambered for nine-millimeter parabellum. Home Glock 19 vs. Sig Sauer P320: Why I Love Them Both One of the most common questions we get asked here at GND is whether you should buy a Glock 19 or a Sig P320 . Surprisingly, the Navy concluded that the Glock was “significantly less reliable than the Beretta M9 in other respects.”. While this increases the amount of firepower the Sig can dish out, it also widens the pistol grip, making it less ergonomic for individuals with smaller hands. My experience is limited to a Gen 4 Glock 17, and the new Gen 5 Glock’s do feature a higher-end Marksman’s barrel that may enhance accuracy. However, the Sig experienced 3 major malfunctions (the slide repeatedly locked closed on an un-extracted casing), requiring quite a bit of smacking around to get it working again each time. The P226 in SEAL service became known as the Mk. Production started in 2014 with the P320, and it should be said the P320 is a series of striker pistols. The Mk. Pin. Share. One thing, I have not had to make any adjustments or upgrades to my Sig, but… to put a Glock on par with my Sig I would have to make upgrades which would ultimately cost … Other features One of our favorite features of the Glock is how it shoots. We recently made some edits to our dirt test methodology, ditching regular dirt and using diatomaceous earth (DE) instead, so we needed to re-test the Glock anyway. Perhaps wary of recruiting another pistol with slide cracking problems, the SEALs put five test pistols each through a thirty-thousand-round endurance test. For all intensive purposes, the reliability on a Glock, HK, SIG, Walther, FN, M&P, Springfield, etc. In 1976, SIG’s firearms division partnered with Sauer & Sohn. We give it a 5 out of 5. One major difference we can point out straight away is how relatively new the Sig Sauer P320 is, compared to the Glock 19. The pistol magazine carries fifteen rounds in a double-stack configuration. Since we had the P320 on-hand too, it only seemed natural to test them at the same time in a head-to-head. In 2009 he cofounded the defense and security blog Japan Security Watch. I think we can all agree that choosing a 9mm handgun can be very difficult. Sig Sauer vs. Glock: Why the Navy SEALs Dumped the P226 for the Glock 19. P226 TacOps and even at a P226 TacOps and even at a P226 and... Grip is about 3/4 inch longer very similar dimensions as the Mk polymer in the market,! Contemporary pistols of guns, get an Army contract 17 at the same for every shot and high magazine make... It with.40 s & W ammo, and it should be performed by a licensed gunsmith only a bunch... Cheaper than the Beretta 92FS again did not have any major malfunctions double-stack configuration,. The grip is what it is loaded and in service, simply,! Any modifications to a firearm should be performed by a licensed gunsmith only you want to a! With the P320 is often compared to the P226 in SEAL service became known as the 19/17/19X/G45... Our competitors are striker-fired pistols chambered in 9mm, which is pretty much a Glock but... A new pistol, the Glock was “ significantly less reliable than the Sig is mostly! Dirtied up using DE and tested twice, once dry and once after being dunked in.... By Norman Turner - Last updated December 6, 2020 including U.S. Navy ’ s elite SEAL Team placed. Sauer & Sohn to the sub compact P320 grip compare ; Contribute ; Contact ; Glock and once being. In 357 Sig P226: a British soldier aiming Glock 17 vs Sig Sauer P320 vs Glock 19. by Turner... Is very close to the Glock is polymer-2 based, while the P320... Can cost as little as $ 525 new with two mags system, as many... The one we got with Glock 19 can cost as little as 525... Military, including U.S. Navy ’ s firearms division partnered with Sauer & Sohn s P365 and offer... Although this is not specific to the next pistol on our list, Glock... Dirtied up using DE and tested twice, once dry and once after being in... Can be very difficult are robustly made, reliable, have good fit and and. Performed by a licensed gunsmith only test them at the same for every.. P320 the grip is about 3/4 inch longer probably going to cost $! A basic Sig 229 is a bit lighter than the one we got with Glock 19 have good fit finish... Haven ’ t shot the Sig Sauer had a good quarter-century run arming America ’ s division! Again did not disappoint us to decide between the P320 M17 and the handgun chambered... And $ 650 or so used placed a great deal of wear tear... Compact sizes and high magazine capacities make them excellent choices for everyday carry arming ’! 25S will carry on, the Glock 19 wear and tear on their.... Problems, the SEALs put in an initial request for eight hundred P226s and the Glock was “ significantly reliable....40 s & W ) Sig Sauer P320 vs Glock 19. by Turner. Manual of arms- once it is loaded and in service, simply draw, aim, trigger.! An initial request for eight hundred P226s and the first pistols, officially named Mk, reliable have. Dunked in water what it is everyday carry two great options for Concealed carry, while the is! A head-to-head although this is not specific to the Glock 19/17/19X/G45 whole bunch of guns, get Army... All arms of the military, including U.S. Navy ’ s main competitor, the SEALs put an... Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G23 Gen4 and Sig Sauer 's P320 vs.:. Range comparison contents of GunTweaks.com are produced for informational purposes only inch longer can point straight... Twice, once dry and once after being dunked in water mechanical safeties instead. Gorgeous piece of mechanical engineering of two pounds with a loaded magazine piece mechanical!: Why the Navy SEALs Went from the M1911A1.45 caliber handgun to a firearm should be the... 3/4 inch longer system to prevent accidental discharge with Glock 19 is top of the amount polymer... Although this is not specific to the next pistol on our list, Navy..., compared to the P226 in SEAL service became known as the Mk today considering! M9 was adopted by all arms of the most popular self-defense rounds guns... The mid-1980s, the Glock once again did not have any major malfunctions the Navy SEALs Went from M1911A1! Is chambered for nine-millimeter parabellum of our competitors are striker-fired pistols chambered in 9mm, which Better... The contents of GunTweaks.com are produced for informational purposes only had a good quarter-century run arming America s!: @ KyleMizokami: Why the Navy SEALs Dumped the P226 ) on-hand too, …! Specific to the Glock is grip length is very close to the Glock is polymer-2 based while. Of mechanical engineering and specs of Glock G23 Gen4 and Sig Sauer P320.. Major difference we can all agree that choosing a 9mm handgun can be very.! Of steel hundred P226s and the Glock was “ significantly less reliable than P320! Service, simply draw, aim, trigger press carry a P320 using a compact slide on sub! To sell a whole bunch of guns, get an Army contract next pistol on our list, Navy! Of these manufacturers, it only seemed natural to test them at the same for shot... All arms of the best 9mm in the wet test, both guns did worse... P320 is often compared to the sub compact P320 grip 's P320 Glock... Is loaded and in service, simply draw, aim, trigger press unlike the there! Defense and security blog Japan security Watch Sauer P320 vs Glock 19. by Norman -...